Annually, Starbucks, Dunkin’ and different espresso retailers announce the drop of the beloved pumpkin spice latte, all the time inciting an uproar amongst shoppers. It creates a divide between those that assume August is just too early to introduce an Autumn staple, and those that would camp out in a single day for his or her first style of a PSL within the useless warmth of summertime. It’s an age-old debate that stands alongside how early vacation music ought to be performed in shops and on the radio, or when it is simply too late to take down the Christmas tree. As a society, we’re consistently discovering ourselves arguing over how early vacation merchandise seems in shops, but it appears to point out up earlier and earlier annually.
What we’re seeing is a dissonance between speeding time and easily having fun with the second, however the root of this fixed development is seasonality and it’s a cornerstone to buyer satisfaction.
Seasonally Acceptable Choices vs. Buyer Happiness
The established order isn’t the end-all-be-all with regards to the appropriateness of seasonal menu choices, even when it sparks disagreement. It could act as a guidepost for understanding what shoppers need when they need it, however eating places have the final word say in when a sure menu merchandise is launched. The fact is that there are shoppers who will purchase a seasonal merchandise whatever the time of 12 months, they usually is probably not the bulk.
Taking part in with the timing of seasonal gadgets is a part of the one-on-one relationship manufacturers try to make with their clients to present them what they need, when they need it, even when it could not but be seasonally applicable. In reality, any manufacturers that introduced a pumpkin-flavored drink or jack-o-lantern-shaped deal with in August had been proper on development. In 2024, Oreo launched its pumpkin spice cookie on August 15, per week earlier than Starbucks dropped its pumpkin line of drinks on August 22, with Dunkin’ trailing behind on August 28. This 12 months, Dunkin’ took the trace, launching its pumpkin spice menu on August 20, with Starbuck set to begin serving theirs on August 26.
In the meantime, Autumn doesn’t start till September 22 – a complete month later – but a whole bunch of hundreds of thousands of Pumpkin Spice Lattes have been offered over time, marking it a fan favourite no matter timing.
The underside line is that eating places are merely giving clients what they need, the inspiration for good customer support. It’d appear like it gained’t make a distinction if the PSL was rolled out a month later, when realistically, it boosts buyer happiness and restaurant gross sales. Eating places see demand skyrocket for seasonal menu gadgets as a result of they’re merely not out there year-round, giving them a type of unique standing. For the patron, it’s an analogous mindset of “get it now whereas it’s out there” and a few might discover themselves flocking to Starbucks rather more usually within the fall than every other time of 12 months.

Seasons Come and Go, and So Ought to Pumpkin Spice Bliss
The seasonal exclusivity of the pumpkin spice latte is what drives clients to buy extra when these things are launched. They don’t wish to miss out scoring the season’s scrumptious deal with, and on the time, they need to be part of the second. With seasonality comes the creation of a cultural second that many shoppers wish to be part of. When these choices are first launched, Instagram is greater than seemingly flooded with posts and tales of a member of the family’s first PSL of the season, or an apple cider donut alongside a co-worker’s espresso. It’s a second to be seen as part of the motion.
Nevertheless, these moments should stay unique. Seasonality is precisely that and mustn’t roll over all year long.
By the point Christmas rolls round, the pumpkin spice latte has misplaced its luster, and shoppers are already wanting ahead to peppermint mocha and sugar cookie-flavored drinks, starting the cycle once more. There’s a saturation component that must be taken into consideration. What eating places want to bear in mind when introducing and promoting seasonal choices, is to watch out to not overexpose clients to them. In any other case, they are going to be turned off to these merchandise and it’ll result in a decline in gross sales, and they gained’t purchase them once more. The exclusivity goes away and the product is now not a success. And that decline can occur quicker than the preliminary pleasure.
Take Chick-Fil-A for instance. For the reason that second it opened its doorways, the enterprise closed each Sunday, but it hasn’t deterred any clients. In reality, each location appears to have a drive-thru line that wraps across the parking zone every day. Whereas a single day in the course of the week doesn’t fairly align with seasonal drinks solely out there for 3 months, it nonetheless shares the component of exclusivity holding patrons coming again.
If It’s Working, Let it Be
The cultural debate might by no means subside every season, however the reality of the matter is that seasonality and unique choices are working. Clients are getting what they need, when they need it. Itsolidifies buyer loyalty, will increase gross sales and normally, provides the eating places much more publicity when their launches spark debates.
The underside line is that eating places should consider the shopper, and if seasonality is completed proper, it’s going to win each time.

