A debate on the dangers posed to the way forward for loyalty by Synthetic Intelligence
Early in 2025, Phil Rubin, Founder, Gray Area Issues, shared a viewpoint on this article revealed in The Smart Marketer that for method too many manufacturers and firms, loyalty is caught.
Analysis carried out pre-COVID revealed that 83% of shoppers think about themselves loyal, which they outlined as a willingness to pay a premium or exit of their strategy to do enterprise with a model. Immediately, as COVID fades into reminiscence, practically half of Millennials and Gen Z (45%) report feeling no model loyalty.
Prospects are more and more apathetic in the direction of manufacturers with little or nothing greater than a homogenous loyalty program focusing solely on transactional worth. As Phil notes, Loyalty isn’t a program. It by no means was. A “me too” loyalty program is hardly brand-building or differentiating, particularly with none connection to , or ideally, a higher buyer expertise.
The warning alerts to entrepreneurs ought to be clear. It’s time to take an in depth take a look at how manufacturers join with prospects, ship an acceptable buyer expertise, and construct useful long-term relationships with them that contribute to the enterprise in a significant method.
The Loyalty Unstuck Collection
It’s for that cause that we’re launching the “Loyalty Unstuck” sequence on The Smart Marketer. To kick this off in earnest, we hosted a debate about the way forward for loyalty. Phil Rubin hosted the talk between two well-recognized trade personalities, Steve Bocska, CEO of PUG Interactive and Denis Huré, Founder and CEO, Reward the World.
The controversy was impressed by an article written by Steve, who recommended that loyalty is greater than caught; it’s been killed by Google Gemini, which drew a pointy rebuttal from Denis. Hyperlinks to all of the articles that shaped this sequence are beneath.
This loyalty cage-match contests competing viewpoints from Steve and Denis across the potential affect the brand new Gemini AI-powered buying assistant might have on loyalty advertising. In response to Steve, Google unveiled what might be the loyalty trade’s extinction-causing occasion as the brand new expertise disintermediates manufacturers from their prospects.
Denis holds a view that manufacturers have ample alternative to compete successfully on this new surroundings and that customers will proceed to make buy selections and type loyalty to the manufacturers they patronize based mostly on a holistic evaluation of the model advertising strategy.
This thought-provoking dialog will problem your present considering, awaken you to the promise of synthetic intelligence and make it easier to to craft your personal aggressive technique to win within the new world of data-driven advertising.
Time Stamps for the Time Starved (with some notable sound bites)
Begin: Invoice introduces the Loyalty Unstuck Collection
2:55 – Phil introduces the subject and our presenters
4:20 – Denis Huré opening assertion
6:48 – Steve Bocska opening assertion
8:35 – The controversy rages
10:14 – “The place to begin of all the pieces is behavioral science.” (Denis)
16:33 – “You name it the Zero Click on search, I name it the collapse of the client/model relationship” (Steve)
20:32 – “VML Future 100 report mentioned that 72 p.c of respondents fail to notice any differentiation amongst manufacturers” (Phil)
23:40 – “The antidote to algorithmic decision-making lies within the human reminiscence” (Steve)
31:26 – “AI as an middleman or agent is enjoying the function the model ought to play, which is knowing the client.” (Phil)
41:58 – The function and significance of Belief
46:20 – What companies are most/least inclined to the specter of AI?
51:30 – “There are people who find themselves frightened and those that see alternative.” (Denis)
52:45 – Phil wraps up the dialogue
55:50 – Last ideas from Steve and Denis
Phil Rubin, Founder/CEO, Gray Area Issues (GSM)
Phil is acknowledged worldwide as a loyalty chief and trusted advisor for main international manufacturers. Previous to GSM, he based and led rDialogue, an unbiased loyalty technique and insights “boutique” that was acquired by Bond in 2020. GSM is an innovation and progress advisory that works shoppers in quite a lot of roles to drive worthwhile natural and inorganic progress.
His present focus is on “getting loyalty unstuck,” which incorporates extra consideration on management and organizational challenges. This has resulted in increasing GSM’s providing to incorporate organizational design and retained govt search.
Steve Bocska, CEO, PUG Interactive
Steve is an award-winning engagement designer, brand-customer relationship orchestrator, and enterprise strategist. He has 25+ years of direct expertise within the online game trade, having designed and produced AAA video games for Disney Interactive, Digital Arts, Sega, and Ubisoft which have generated gross sales in extra of $650 million.
PUG Interactive is an award-winning firm that helps enterprises construct unbreakable brand-customer relationships utilizing superior on-line applied sciences and gameplay ideas to drive essential enterprise outcomes. Steve has spoken at quite a lot of premier occasions and is a college member of the Loyalty Academy.
Denis Huré, Founder & CEO, Reward the World™
Denis is a seasoned entrepreneur with a ardour for innovation and expertise. With over twenty years of expertise within the tech trade, he has established himself as a visionary chief. Denis co-founded his first startup after over 15 years of company expertise, the place he honed his expertise in product growth, advertising, and enterprise technique.
All through his profession, Denis has been on the forefront of cutting-edge applied sciences, from synthetic intelligence to blockchain. He has a knack for figuring out rising traits and reworking them into profitable ventures.
Sources
Three-part sequence:

